Plaza Pastry Shop storefront in Nutley, New Jersey

Nutley, New Jersey

Your Family-Owned
Bakery in Nutley

Breads, pastries and cakes for all occasions

Daily 7am–6pm · holiday hours may vary
View Our MenuCall to Order

Your Daily Selection

From Our Bakery

Breads & Rolls

Call for our daily selection

Pastries & Donuts

Explore today's bakery selection

Sandwiches & Stuffed Breads

Call to find out what's available

Custom Cakes

Made to order for all occasions

View Full Menu

A Look Inside Plaza

Our Creations

Sourdough loaves on the bakery shelves
Sourdough loaves on the bakery shelves
Glazed pastries at the bakery counter
Glazed pastries at the bakery counter
Spinach croissants on display
Spinach croissants on display
An assortment of stuffed breads
An assortment of stuffed breads
Bread loaves and rolls lining the shelves
Bread loaves and rolls lining the shelves
Chicken and beef pot pies at the counter
Chicken and beef pot pies at the counter
Donuts and sweet pastries on bakery trays
Donuts and sweet pastries on bakery trays
Pastry display cases inside Plaza Pastry Shop
Pastry display cases inside Plaza Pastry Shop

Explore Our Menu

Browse by Category

Sourdough loaves on display

Breads

Bread rolls stacked on the bakery shelves

Rolls

An assortment of glazed pastries

Pastries

Donuts on trays in the bakery case

Donuts

Labeled varieties of stuffed bread

Stuffed Breads

Ready to taste the difference?

Call 973-661-0011 to order or ask about availability. Open every day, 7am–6pm; holiday hours may vary. No delivery.

Call to OrderGet Directions